That Long Silence By Shashi Deshpande: A comprehensive analysis

-

Shashi Deshpande’s novel That Long Silence, first published in 1988, is a poignant and thought-provoking work that delves deeply into the psychological and emotional world of an Indian woman, Jaya, who confronts her own silence, struggles, and identity in a patriarchal society. This novel is not merely a narrative about one woman’s life; it is a mirror reflecting the inner lives of many Indian women who experience marginalization, repression, and voicelessness within the frameworks of tradition, marriage, and social expectations.

Awarded the Sahitya Akademi Award in 1990, That Long Silence stands as a landmark feminist text in Indian English literature. Deshpande’s sensitive portrayal of a woman’s inner turmoil, combined with her subtle yet powerful critique of gender roles, makes the novel both universal and intimately Indian. The narrative focuses on the protagonist Jaya’s journey from suppressed silence to tentative self-awareness, and her eventual decision to break that long silence that has defined her life.

Plot Overview

The novel opens with Jaya and her husband Mohan temporarily relocating to a small flat in Bombay due to an ongoing investigation into Mohan’s professional misconduct. This disruption from their comfortable life prompts Jaya to reflect upon her marriage, her role as a wife and mother, her past choices, and the silence that has dominated her existence.

As the story unfolds, Jaya recounts various episodes from her life — her childhood, her marriage to Mohan, the deaths and conflicts in her family, her relationship with her children, and her aspirations as a writer. Through these recollections, readers gain insight into how Jaya has systematically suppressed her voice and desires to conform to societal expectations of a “good” Indian woman.

The novel ends on a quiet but significant note of resolve, where Jaya recognizes the necessity of reclaiming her voice, acknowledging her truth, and living life with authenticity rather than resignation.

Character Analysis

Jaya

Jaya is the central character and narrator of the novel. A well-educated woman, she once had literary ambitions and a desire for independence. However, over the course of her marriage, she sacrifices her individuality to maintain harmony in her domestic life. She adapts to the roles of wife and mother but feels emotionally stifled and disconnected.

Jaya’s name, meaning “victory,” is ironic, as her life is marked not by triumph but by silence, submission, and emotional defeat. Her narrative is an introspective journey through which she slowly comes to understand how she has internalized patriarchal values and silenced her own voice in order to be accepted, loved, and safe.

Jaya's journey is not dramatic or revolutionary, but deeply personal and emotional. By the end of the novel, she begins to embrace the idea that change must begin from within, and that breaking the silence is the first step toward asserting her identity.

Mohan

Mohan is Jaya’s husband and represents the traditional Indian male who expects his wife to conform to established gender norms. He is not physically abusive or overtly tyrannical, but his control is subtle and psychological. Mohan's need for respectability and order shapes the kind of relationship he expects from Jaya — obedient, supportive, and unchallenging.

Mohan’s inability to understand Jaya's emotional needs and his discomfort with her opinions highlight the gender gap in emotional communication. Even though he is not villainous, he symbolizes the systemic patriarchy that confines women to silent, supporting roles.

Supporting Characters

  • Vanitamami and Ramukaka: These relatives represent the traditional mindset of older generations, emphasizing duty, silence, and endurance, especially for women.

  • Mukta: A widow and Jaya’s acquaintance, Mukta is a figure of female suffering. Her life, filled with loss and dependence, contrasts sharply with Jaya’s, yet both women share the burden of silence.

  • Kusum: Jaya’s cousin, who suffers a mental breakdown and eventually dies by suicide, is a haunting symbol of what can happen when the pressure to conform overwhelms a person. Kusum’s tragedy is a warning of the dangers of internalized repression.

  • Rahul and Rati: Jaya’s children play minor but symbolic roles. Her relationship with them, especially the growing distance from Rahul, mirrors her own emotional isolation.

Major Themes

1. Silence and Voice

The most central theme in That Long Silence is that of silence — not just literal silence but the metaphorical suppression of self-expression. Jaya’s silence is a product of her social conditioning. She has learned that a woman’s role is to maintain peace by suppressing her desires, thoughts, and opinions. Her silence is not just about fear; it is about survival within the domestic sphere.

However, this silence is also what suffocates her. Through her introspection, Jaya begins to see that her silence has kept her emotionally distant from her husband and children. The novel traces her journey towards realizing the importance of having a voice, of articulating her truth, and of speaking even when it is difficult.

2. Gender Roles and Patriarchy

Deshpande meticulously critiques the expectations placed upon women in Indian society. From childhood, Jaya is taught to be compliant and self-sacrificing. Her identity is always tied to others — as a daughter, wife, and mother — never as an individual. Marriage becomes a space where she is expected to perform roles, not express herself.

The novel explores how patriarchy functions not just through overt oppression but through subtle expectations, social conditioning, and emotional manipulation. Mohan, who believes he has given Jaya everything, cannot understand that what she truly lacks is freedom — the freedom to be herself.

3. Identity and Selfhood

The question of identity is crucial in the novel. Jaya, despite her education and intelligence, has no clear sense of who she is outside of her familial roles. Her foray into writing, which could have been a path to self-expression, is curtailed when Mohan disapproves of her published story because it resembled their private life.

Jaya’s journey is about reclaiming her identity. She realizes that she has been living a life of inauthenticity — smiling, conforming, and pleasing others at the cost of her own truth. By the end of the novel, she begins to envision a life where she can live honestly, even if it means facing discomfort and conflict.

4. Marriage and Communication

Marriage in the novel is portrayed as a socially sanctioned institution that often demands compromise from women. Jaya and Mohan’s marriage appears functional but lacks emotional intimacy. They are unable to communicate openly, and Jaya is expected to mask her feelings to preserve the illusion of harmony.

The breakdown of communication is not due to hatred or abuse but due to deeply ingrained gender roles that prevent real emotional connection. The novel reveals how marriage can become a prison when partners cannot speak freely.

5. Female Suffering and Solidarity

Deshpande portrays various female characters who suffer in silence — Kusum, Mukta, Vanitamami — each representing a different facet of female repression. These women are not given dramatic arcs or revolutionary escapes. Instead, they endure, and their endurance becomes a quiet tragedy.

However, Jaya’s reflection on these women also becomes a source of awareness. She realizes that her suffering is not unique and that silence has been passed down through generations. This recognition is the beginning of her awakening and suggests a sense of solidarity among women, even if unspoken.

Narrative Style and Structure

The novel is written in a first-person, introspective style, allowing readers to intimately experience Jaya’s thoughts, memories, and realizations. The narrative moves back and forth in time — from present events in the flat with Mohan to past memories of childhood, family, and marriage — mirroring the way the mind works during moments of self-reflection.

Deshpande’s language is clear, restrained, and sensitive. She avoids sensationalism or melodrama. Instead, the emotional impact is built slowly through quiet observations, inner conflict, and personal honesty. The tone is melancholic but never hopeless, and the narrative builds toward a resolution that is subtle yet empowering.

Symbolism

  • The Flat: The temporary flat represents a liminal space, away from social pretenses. It becomes a place where Jaya is forced to confront herself and her marriage.

  • Water Imagery: Water, particularly in moments such as Jaya’s dream of drowning, symbolizes emotional suffocation and her desire for freedom. It also suggests the fluidity and depth of her thoughts.

  • The Name “Jaya”: Meaning “victory,” the name symbolizes a potential for triumph over repression, although that victory is internal and emotional rather than social.

Feminist Perspective

From a feminist perspective, That Long Silence is a landmark work in Indian literature. Deshpande does not advocate rebellion in a loud or violent way. Instead, she reveals the deep psychological and emotional cost of living in a society where women are expected to be silent, obedient, and invisible.

Jaya’s growth is inward, emotional, and intellectual. Deshpande portrays feminism as the right to self-expression, the right to choose, and the right to be authentic. The novel’s feminist power lies in its honesty, in its refusal to glamorize or vilify, and in its recognition that even small acts of self-awareness are revolutionary in a repressive environment.

Conclusion

That Long Silence is a deeply introspective and powerful novel that explores a woman’s psychological journey from silence to self-realization. Through Jaya’s reflections, Shashi Deshpande exposes the silent suffering of countless women who are trapped in the roles assigned by society, marriage, and tradition. The novel’s strength lies in its emotional honesty, nuanced characters, and quiet but persistent questioning of patriarchal norms.

Though the novel ends without dramatic action, Jaya’s internal shift is profound. She resolves to break her silence — not with loud protest, but with a renewed sense of self, a quiet courage to live truthfully. This ending is symbolic of Deshpande’s belief in the importance of inner strength and the transformative power of self-awareness.

In That Long Silence, silence is not just the absence of speech; it is the erasure of identity. And breaking that silence is not merely about speaking out — it is about rediscovering one's voice, reclaiming one’s truth, and, ultimately, embracing the self.

Popular posts from this blog

"Cry, the Peacock": A Detailed Summary and Analysis

-
Introduction Cry, the Peacock is Anita Desai ’s first novel. It was published in 1963. The novel explores a woman’s emotional struggles and her experience of loneliness and despair. The story focuses on Maya, the main character, and her troubled marriage. She suffers from isolation and mental instability. Anita Desai presents the fragility of the human mind and the difficulties of marriage. Brief Summary The novel takes place in post-independence India. However, the story focuses more on personal struggles than political events. Maya is a young woman who lives with her husband, Gautama. Gautama is a practical and intellectual man. He does not show emotions, and he does not understand Maya’s feelings. Maya is sensitive and emotional. She wants love and affection, but Gautama does not give her the attention she needs. Maya feels lonely and neglected. She spends most of her time thinking about her life. She creates fantasies in her mind to escape her loneliness. One important symbol in t...
Read more

Phonetics and Phonology : Definition and difference

-
Phonetics and phonology are two closely related subfields of linguistics that both deal with the sounds of speech, but they focus on different aspects of these sounds. Phonetics is the study of the physical properties of speech sounds, specifically how they are produced, transmitted, and perceived. It is concerned with the actual sounds themselves—how they are articulated, how they travel through the air as sound waves, and how they are received by the ear and processed by the brain. Phonetics is typically divided into three subfields: 1. Articulatory Phonetics : This branch focuses on the physical production of speech sounds. It looks at the movements of the vocal organs (such as the tongue, lips, and vocal cords) and how these movements create different speech sounds. It studies how different places and manners of articulation (e.g., voicing, nasality, consonant types like stops or fricatives) contribute to the production of speech. 2. Acoustic Phonetics : This branch is concerned w...
Read more

Dhwani Theory by Anandvardhana: an introduction

-
Anandvardhana was a Kashmiri court poet and literary critic, honored with the title of Rajanak during King Avantivarman's reign.  Anandavardhana authored the Dhvanyāloka , or A Light on Suggestion (dhwani), a work articulating the philosophy of "aesthetic suggestion" (dhwani, vyañjanā). Anandavardhana is credited with creating the dhwani theory. He wrote that dhwani (meaning sound, or evocation) is the "soul" or "essence" (ātman) of poetry (kavya).  Anandavardhana said, "When the poet writes, he creates a eloquent field of emotions." To understand the poetry, the reader or hearer must be on the same wavelength. Important points~ •Dhvani theory is a theory of suggestion that is considered to be the soul of poetry.  •The theory of Dhvani is a major contribution to Sanskrit literary theory.  •The theory of Dhvani suggests that the main goal of good poetry is to evoke a mood or "flavor" (rasa).  •The theory of Dhvani suggests that this...
Read more