Archetypal/Myth criticism
Archetypal and myth criticism are literary theories that analyze texts by identifying universal symbols, themes, and character types that resonate across cultures and time periods. Rooted in the work of Carl Jung and Joseph Campbell, these critical approaches explore how mythological structures and archetypes shape narrative patterns, characters, and the meanings of texts.
Archetypal Criticism stems from the idea that certain patterns, symbols, and character types recur across literature and human experience. Carl Jung, a Swiss psychologist, argued that there are universal symbols, or "archetypes," embedded in the collective unconscious of humanity. These archetypes—such as the hero, the wise old man, the shadow, and the anima/animus—reflect deep, instinctual aspects of the human psyche. Archetypal critics examine how these recurring figures and motifs manifest in a work of literature to provide insight into the characters’ motivations and the thematic elements of a story. For example, in a hero's journey, the protagonist often undergoes a transformation, confronting challenges that reflect personal growth or the battle between good and evil.
In archetypal criticism, critics also look at structural patterns within stories, such as the journey, the fall, or the redemption cycle. Joseph Campbell’s concept of the "monomyth," or the hero's journey, is an essential framework in this approach. According to Campbell, the hero’s journey is a narrative template found in myths across cultures, where the hero ventures forth, faces trials, and returns transformed. Analyzing a work through the lens of archetypes and myth can reveal deeper meanings about the human condition, society’s values, and the psychological forces at play in the text.
Myth Criticism, closely related to archetypal criticism, extends the idea of archetypes to explore the myths and legends that shape cultures and influence literary works. This approach examines how a text engages with or retells traditional myths, often highlighting how contemporary stories reflect or subvert ancient mythological themes. Myth critics argue that myths are not only stories but also embody cultural values and truths. They often interpret literature through the lens of collective myths, exploring how modern stories echo the rituals, beliefs, and existential struggles of ancient societies. For example, many works of literature incorporate elements from Greek mythology, such as the story of Oedipus, the Iliad, or the Odyssey, and these can be read as modern adaptations of ancient archetypes and myths.
The focus on mythology allows critics to explore the ways in which literature reflects shared human experiences. Myth criticism often examines the symbolic meanings behind mythological motifs, such as the hero’s quest for identity or the struggle between order and chaos, considering how these elements appear across genres, periods, and cultural contexts.
Thus, both archetypal and myth criticism delve into the universal aspects of human experience, seeking connections between the individual text and broader cultural narratives. By revealing recurring symbols, motifs, and structures, these approaches help illuminate the psychological, emotional, and cultural forces at work in literature, offering deeper insights into the meaning and significance of a work. Through the study of archetypes and myths, critics can uncover how literature resonates with timeless human concerns, from identity and morality to existential questions of life and death.