Crisis in Orientalism

-

Crisis in Orientalism – Summary

Edward Said’s work Crisis in Orientalism is a crucial section of his groundbreaking book Orientalism (1978), where he critiques the Western study of the East, arguing that it is deeply rooted in colonial power structures. In this essay, Said explores the intellectual and moral crisis faced by traditional Orientalists as their field is challenged by emerging critical perspectives.

Key Points of the Work:

  1. The Crisis of Legitimacy in Orientalism
    Said argues that Orientalism, the Western study of the East, has been a long-standing intellectual tradition that shaped European and American perceptions of the Orient. However, by the mid-20th century, this field faced a crisis as scholars from the formerly colonized regions began questioning the authority of Western academics to represent Eastern societies.

    "The major shift in the study of the Orient has been the emergence of the Orient itself as a politically and intellectually independent entity."

  2. Challenge to Objectivity and Authority
    Traditional Orientalists claimed to study the East with scientific objectivity, but Said exposes how their work was intertwined with colonial power. He critiques scholars like Bernard Lewis, who resisted recognizing the political implications of their research. Instead of a neutral academic field, Orientalism is revealed as a discourse of power that justified Western dominance.

    "The fact that the Orientalist was neither interested in nor capable of discussing the Orient on the same level as a Westerner shows the fundamental bias in the field."

  3. Decolonization and the Rise of Postcolonial Scholarship
    With the rise of national liberation movements in Asia and Africa, native scholars began producing knowledge about their own histories and cultures. This shift undermined Orientalism’s credibility, leading to a crisis in the discipline. Scholars from the Global South rejected the Eurocentric framework and demanded new, decolonized perspectives.

    "The challenge of postcolonial scholarship lies in its demand for a recognition of the Orient not as an object of study but as a subject of its own history."

  4. The End of Traditional Orientalism?
    Said suggests that while classical Orientalism is in crisis, its legacy persists in modern forms, such as media representations and political discourse. Western portrayals of the Middle East in journalism and policy-making still reflect Orientalist stereotypes. This means that while academia has evolved, the core issues remain.

    "Although the old Orientalist has disappeared, a new Orientalism has taken its place in political and media discourses, shaping perceptions of the Middle East."

Conclusion

Crisis in Orientalism highlights how Western scholarship on the East has been shaped by colonial interests and how its legitimacy has been challenged by postcolonial critiques. Said’s analysis remains relevant today, as Orientalist narratives continue to influence Western foreign policy and cultural representations.

Popular Posts

"Cry, the Peacock": A Detailed Summary and Analysis

-
Introduction Cry, the Peacock is Anita Desai ’s first novel. It was published in 1963. The novel explores a woman’s emotional struggles and her experience of loneliness and despair. The story focuses on Maya, the main character, and her troubled marriage. She suffers from isolation and mental instability. Anita Desai presents the fragility of the human mind and the difficulties of marriage. Brief Summary The novel takes place in post-independence India. However, the story focuses more on personal struggles than political events. Maya is a young woman who lives with her husband, Gautama. Gautama is a practical and intellectual man. He does not show emotions, and he does not understand Maya’s feelings. Maya is sensitive and emotional. She wants love and affection, but Gautama does not give her the attention she needs. Maya feels lonely and neglected. She spends most of her time thinking about her life. She creates fantasies in her mind to escape her loneliness. One important symbol in t...
Read more

Phonetics and Phonology : Definition and difference

-
Phonetics and phonology are two closely related subfields of linguistics that both deal with the sounds of speech, but they focus on different aspects of these sounds. Phonetics is the study of the physical properties of speech sounds, specifically how they are produced, transmitted, and perceived. It is concerned with the actual sounds themselves—how they are articulated, how they travel through the air as sound waves, and how they are received by the ear and processed by the brain. Phonetics is typically divided into three subfields: 1. Articulatory Phonetics : This branch focuses on the physical production of speech sounds. It looks at the movements of the vocal organs (such as the tongue, lips, and vocal cords) and how these movements create different speech sounds. It studies how different places and manners of articulation (e.g., voicing, nasality, consonant types like stops or fricatives) contribute to the production of speech. 2. Acoustic Phonetics : This branch is concerned w...
Read more

Dhwani Theory by Anandvardhana: an introduction

-
Anandvardhana was a Kashmiri court poet and literary critic, honored with the title of Rajanak during King Avantivarman's reign.  Anandavardhana authored the Dhvanyāloka , or A Light on Suggestion (dhwani), a work articulating the philosophy of "aesthetic suggestion" (dhwani, vyaΓ±janā). Anandavardhana is credited with creating the dhwani theory. He wrote that dhwani (meaning sound, or evocation) is the "soul" or "essence" (ātman) of poetry (kavya).  Anandavardhana said, "When the poet writes, he creates a eloquent field of emotions." To understand the poetry, the reader or hearer must be on the same wavelength. Important points~ •Dhvani theory is a theory of suggestion that is considered to be the soul of poetry.  •The theory of Dhvani is a major contribution to Sanskrit literary theory.  •The theory of Dhvani suggests that the main goal of good poetry is to evoke a mood or "flavor" (rasa).  •The theory of Dhvani suggests that this...
Read more